Name |
|
Empiricism
Locke,
Hume, Berkeley
|
All knowledge comes from experienceHistorically, empiricism was a
reaction against the excesses of scholasticism and medieval rationalism.
The classic empiricists were John Locke (1632-1704), George Berkeley (1685-1753),
and David Hume (1711-1776), who, along with earlier thinkers like Francis
Bacon (1561-1626), attempted to put science on a more solid footing by
making knowledge inductive and reality-based instead of deductive and theoretical
the empiricists being inspired by the belief that experience is the only
reliable source of knowledge. Unfortunately, Lockes epistemological views
tended towards representationalism, so that the empirical tradition went
astray and ended up caught in the snares of Hume's skepticism and subjectivism.
Popularly, empiricism is a positive term, connected as it is with science
and with practical action (similar in this sense to pragmatism).
|
|
Instrumentalism
John
Dewy
|
Concepts to be verified though
empiricism, looser as it allows conceptual analysis.
Instrumentalism is the idea that
concepts are merely useful instruments, and that the proper way to evaluate
concepts and propositions is not through the categories of truth and falsity
but through judging their effectiveness; the view developed out of and
is somewhat similar to pragmatism.
|
|
Pragmatism
Dewey, James
|
Values, meaning, and truths
of propositions are equivalent to the practical, empirical consequences
derivable from them.
Pragmatism is generally considered
to be the only truly philosophical school and tradition to have emerged
in America (mainly because it is more technically rigorous than transcendentalism).
While the term itself was originated by C.S. Pierce, pragmatism's most
famous exponents were William James and John Dewey, although there were
numerous lesser figures involved during its heyday in the late nineteenth
and early twentieth centuries (G.H. Mead, F.S.C. Schiller, etc.). The original
formulation of pragmatism by Pierce applied to epistemology (the idea that
knowledge must be tested by its usefulness), but the concept was quickly
extended by James. Pragmatism in ethics is a form of consequentialism,
but it differs from utilitarianism in that pragmatism emphasizes action
while utilitarianism emphasizes usefulness (Greek pragma = "action" while
Latin utilis = "use"). Pragmatism is often said to be a kind of humanism,
since it stresses the importance of meeting human needs and the real interests
of human beings. Unfortunately, pragmatism rejects any kind of ethical
naturalism and tends to be a kind of relativism. In popular usage, to say
that a person is pragmatic may indicate that he or she lacks principles,
although it can simply be a positive statement that he or she has a can-do
attitude" or "knows how to get things done".
|
|
Monism
Spinoza,
Hegel
|
There is only one kind of reality
or substance.
|
|
Dualism
Plato,
Descartes, Titchener
|
Two separate states of nature
or two sets of fundamental principles in the universe: separate, parallel,
and interacting.
Dualism is a doctrine in metaphysics
which posits that there are only two fundamental things or substances or
constituents of things in the world at large or in the human soul. The
first influential dualist theory in the West was Platonism, which claimed
that there are actually two different worlds: the physical world of appearances
and the higher world of intelligible Forms or Ideas or Essences (thus note
the common connection of dualism to transcendentalism and idealism), with
a similar separation in the human person between mind and body. These ideas
were picked up by Stoicism and, later, by Christianity. Thus the idea of
dualism was current throughout the Christian era but it received a renewed
impetus from Descartes, who held that reality is made up exclusively of
Spirit and Matter, and that these two substances can never meet or interact
except in the human soul (which gives rise to the infamous mind-body
dichotomy). Aristotelianism, by contrast, holds that mind and body are
not two distinct substances but two aspects of the something, of the same
complete human person (cf. also holism).
|
|
Pluralism
Leibniz,
Russell
|
Ultimate reality consists of
more than one form of basic substance or principle.
|
|
Interactionism
Descartes
|
Classic dualism: mind and body
are interactive, parallel, and separate.
|
|
Panpsychism
Leibniz, Schopenhauser, Whitehead
|
Every molecule in the universe
is conscious, every object has a soul or mind.
|
|
Idealism
Berkeley,
Kant
|
Ultimate reality is mental and
this forms the basis for experience and knowledge.
In metaphysics, idealism is a term
used to describe the sort of theory, which claims that, something "ideal"
or non-physical is the primary reality. In this sense, Plato and Leibniz
and Hegel are probably the most significant of the idealists (Leibniz is
perhaps the most consistent, since he said that all physical things are
actually made up of little bundles of consciousness he called "monads",
an idea that is a kind of "panpsychism"). Obviously, spiritualism is similar
to idealism, but spiritualism tends to be used to refer more to religious,
supernatural conceptions of reality, rather than to philosophical theories
like those of Plato or Hegel. Plato can be considered the "Founding Father"
of idealism in Western philosophy, since he claimed that what is fundamentally
real are ideas, of which physical objects are pale imitations. The opposite
of idealism is materialism.
|
|
Fatalism
|
All events are predetermined,
but human action can be causally effective in ensuring what happens.
Fatalism in philosophy holds that
defeat and despair are the ultimate and inescapable fate of man; it is
thus similar to pessimism and nihilism, and is often allied with determinism.
In popular usage, fatalism refers to a tendency to give in to the inevitability
of suffering or to the tragic aspects of life negative instead of positive
thinking.
|
|
Determinism
|
All events, including human actions,
are predetermined.
Determinism is the belief that
all physical events and human actions are determined or settled by external
forces before they happen. In other words, determinists deny the existence
of freely chosen human activity, and the more consistent determinists even
deny any personal responsibility for human actions.
|
|
Occasionalism
Malebranche
|
Matter is moved through divine
intervention: expressing will is the occasion for such intervention.
|
|
Representalism
Descartes
|
The mind does not directly perceive
the world but does only through the concepts that represent the world.
In epistemology, representationalism
is the view that the only things we can know are our representations of
the world (e.g., ideas, perceptions, beliefs, etc.), not the world itself.
Epistemological representationalism is therefore opposed to realism, especially
to direct realism.
|
|
Externalism
|
Internal thoughts are represented
or manifested in external world.
|
|
Rationalism
Plato,
Chomsky
|
Truth to be obtained through
use of reason and rational thought.
The first philosophers who are
usually called rationalists were Descartes (1596-1650), Leibniz (1646-1716),
and Spinoza (1632-1677). While they claimed to be defending science against
scholasticism, their arguments often showed little improvement over those
of their opposition. For example, Descartes' defence of science consisted
of a dualism from which philosophy is still recovering, and his arguments
for dualism were models of rationalism: technical, deductive, and extremely
abstract. Spinoza's Ethics (which often seems to have little to do with
ethics) is the high point of rationalism in philosophy: it is totally deductive
and modelled on the geometric system of Euclid's Elements. Rationalism,
in its deductive and abstract way of reasoning, tends to prefer the "harder"
branches of philosophy (such as epistemology) almost totally ignores ethical
and political concerns. The word rationalism is often used to refer to
such an overly deductive way of thinking and to the moulding of reality
to fit one's theoretical understanding, but this isomer of a psychological
characterization than a philosophical definition.
|
|
Objectivism
|
Moral truths exist independent
of whether they are believed or practised.
The term 'objectivism' refers to
the idea that reality exists outside of the mind and that existents retain
their identity no matter what human beings or other conscious creatures
think or feel about it (colloquially captured in the phrase "wishing doesn't
make it so").
|
|
Subjectivism
|
Morality is derived from personal
judgement or preferences.
The term subjectivism (compare
to intrinsicism, contrast with objectivism) refers to any doctrine in a
tradition, stretching all the way back to the Sophists of ancient Greece,
which denies that knowledge and values are in any way based on reality,
and which thus holds that knowledge and values are relative. Not all subjectivists
are completely consistent, of course, because pure, unadulterated subjectivism
is tantamount to solipsism.
|
|
Logical
Positivism
Hume,
Russell, Wittgenstein
|
Any nontautological proposition
that cannot in principle be empirically verified is devoid of meaning
Logical positivism is a movement
in 20th century philosophy that originated as a reaction against nineteenth-century
idealism. The word logical in the name refers to the belief that logic
is all-important for philosophy (thus this movement is a sort of logicism),
while "positivism" here is really a certain form of empiricism which claims
that empiricism is the whole of philosophy and that there is no validity
to anything which could be called conceptual experience or conceptual insight.
|
|
Mentalism
|
Behaviour cannot be explained
without using mental phenomena.
Mentalism is the idea that only
mind or spirit really exists, or that mind or spirit is the fundamental
substance in the universe. Mentalism is sometimes called immaterialism,
and is usually held to be similar to or equivalent to idealism.
|
|
Materialism
Newton, La Mettrie
|
Reality is only known through
understanding of physical matter.
Materialism is the idea that the
only thing that really exists in the world is matter in its various states
and movements (commonly atoms or other physical particles). Thus materialism
is the opposite of idealism. Materialism considers any talk of, say, the
soul to be complete nonsense and a throwback to the bad old days of spiritualism
and vitalism (i.e., idealism) in philosophy. Note that because matter can
be completely known by means of physical laws and mathematical description
(see reductionism), materialism tends to be used to lend heavy support
to determinism.
|
|
Mechanism
Descartes
|
All phenomena can be understood
in a mechanical framework: living things are essentially just machines.
|
|
Realism
Duns
Scotus
|
Abstract concepts have a real
existence and can be empirically studied.
The word realism in philosophy
has many senses, and this fact can lead to confusion. The idea that we
can and do possess reliable knowledge, both perceptual and conceptual,
about reality is known as epistemological realism (obviously a kind of
optimism about the possibility of knowledge). In the psychology and philosophy
of perception, realism comes in two flavors: direct and indirect (direct
realism being the truly realistic position namely that we perceive the
actually existing physical world whereas indirect realism is often a
form of representationalism). Confusingly, realism with regard to the arts
is often called representationalism. There is also the metaphysical realism
(or objectivism) of most forms of Aristotelianism: the idea that reality
is what it is and possesses an independent identity, regardless of the
beliefs of the observer. However, sometimes when people talk about realism
in philosophy or metaphysics they are really talking about what I define
as intrinsicism, since historically realism was often contrasted with nominalism
and was equated with idealism and intrinsicism. Popularly, realism refers
to a healthy scepticism about what can be achieved through action or sometimes
to alack of ideals or principles (see pragmatism).
|
Name |
Explanation
|
|
Essentialism
|
There is a world of perfect essences
of which the exemplars in the actual world are flawed examples
1) Platonic idealism; 2) the view
that all things have essential properties which can be discerned by reason
(sometimes attributed to Aristotelianism)
|
|
Functionalism
Angell,
Carr, Putnam
|
Mind and behaviour should be
studied in terms of functions or utilities rather than contents; thus,
mental states are functional states
|
|
Existentialism
Sartre
|
Personal decision making to be
made in world without reason or purpose.
Existentialism is an influential
movement in 20th century philosophy and especially ethics. Historically,
existentialism was inspired by the supposed skepticism and nihilism of
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900). Existentialism takes its peculiar character
from the fact that, even though it is a form of individualism, it is also
very much akin of pessimism another major influence on existentialism
was Schopenhauer. According to Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980), the leading
philosopher of the movement, existentialism takes its name from its guiding
phrase, "existence precedes essence". This means that there is no stable
human essence or nature and thus that there are no intrinsic or natural
human values (so that any attempt at ethical naturalism is misguided and
debased). Existentialism teaches that each person must simply live his
life and by so doing create his own values, almost as an afterthought.
Although such a process of living cane haphazard and lacking in self-direction,
this fact does not seem to be a problem for the existentialists. In fact,
some existentialists even revel in the unplanned, irrational character
of life and therefore could be characterized as proponents of irrationalism
or even nihilism.
|
|
Phenomenalism
|
Knowledge and understanding
of reality outside appearances is unknowable: In
other words, that appearances, not realities, are the only objects of knowledge.Phenomenalism
is thus a form of epistemological subjectivism or relativism.
|
|
Operationalism
Bridgeman
|
Concepts of science are defined
by, and limited to, the operations used in their measurement.
|
|
Selectionism
Darwin
|
Species are not essences or
types but the resultof selection
from variation.
|
|
Reductionism
Skinner,
Watson
|
Break down of phenomena into
fundamental aspects.
|
|
Behaviourism
Watson,
Skinner, Pavlov
|
Only subject matter for scientific
measurement is observed measurable behaviour.
Behaviorism was an influential
movement among psychologists, founded by John D. Watson in 1913, made famous
by B.F. Skinner, and continually popular (at least among academics) throughout
the twentieth century. Behaviorism amounts to reductionism and materialism
applied to action a reduction of human and animal activity to simple
stimulus and response, excluding any functional role for consciousness.
Behaviorism has lost much of its lustre and has been replaced in the fancy
of psychologists by the computer model of human cognition, which of course
is simply another kind of reductive materialism. In his political manifesto
or utopia Walden Two, B.F. Skinner holds that a kind of communalistic utilitarianism
would result from the application of behaviorism to society, but his seeming
advocacy of eugenics and other such techniques militates against his utopia
being considered a kind of humanism.
|
|
Vitalism
Aristotle
|
Life cannot be explained in purely
material terms: something non-material in living organisms makes them different
from inanimate things.
Vitalism was a reaction against
the currents of materialism and mechanistic determinism in the eighteenth
and nineteenth centuries. The vitalists posited that human beings are not
purely physical but contain some kind of spiritual component or "vital
essence". In practice, since the vitalists could not deny the progress
of materialist science, they advocated a kind of dualism of matter and
life. Vitalism has definite negative connotations of quackery, especially
among those who have respect for science.
|
|
Cognitivism
Marr,
Piaget, Baddeley, Chomsky
|
A reliance on internal, mental
representations and processes to provide all psychological explanation:
information processing approach.
|
|
Theism
|
Belief in God as an omnipotent
and omniscient creator.
|
|
Solipsism
|
Only I exist: the outside world
exists as a content of my consciousness.
Solipsism is subjectivism and relativism
taken to the extreme: the solipsist is so consistent about his doctrine
that he claims that he cannot know if physical reality or other human beings
even exist. The solipsist believes knowledge is so subjective that "all
I can really know is myself"
|
|
Transcendentalism
Kant
|
Any theory asserting the dependence
of the world of experience on the activities of reason: knowledge is beyond
experience, i.e., geometry.
The term transcendentalism refers
in general to any view which holds that there is an aspect of reality that
is higher than (that "transcends") our everyday life and world; in this
primary sense, the term is roughly equivalent to idealism (e.g., Kant is
often called a transcendental idealist), or even to spiritualism (especially
in popular understanding). In America, the word is most often used to refer
to the school or movement of New England transcendentalists during the
nineteenth century, including thinkers like Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803-1882)
and Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862) who, according to some accounts, were
influenced by the German transcendentalists and Kantians of their time.
However, this influence was not very deep (Emerson and Thoreau are much
greater believers in optimism and individualism than their German counterparts);
these thinkers may have been inspired by the example of developments in
Europe, but their doctrines were original to them. The central figure here
was Emerson, who advocated a philosophy of self-reliance and self-fulfillment.
|
|
Taoism
Lao-Tzu
|
Individual enlightenment and
transcendental enjoyment of absolutely free existence.
Taoism is an ancient strand of
Chinese philosophical thought, similar in many ways to Platonism in the
West (just as Confucianism holds a position similar to Aristotelianism).
However, Taoism was a reaction against the conservative and action-oriented
thought of Confucius: one of the central Taoist concepts was wu-wei or
"non-activity". Taoists stress the necessity of living in accordance to
nature (their policy of non-activity could be phrased as "do nothing that
is contrary to nature or to your own native character"), and their doctrines
can be compared to Stoicism in this regard. The Taoist emphasis on lack
of emotion and "disturbance" that is, on inner peace can also be compared
to the doctrines of Epicureanism. Taoist thinkers, foremost among them
Lao Tzu and Chuang Tzu (the two great authors of classical Taoism), stressed
the inherent untrustworthiness of appearances, the unity of the real world
behind the appearances, the necessity of understanding this real unity
"spontaneously", and the cultivation of one's character so that one could
become a "free spirit". Taoism was and is a strong tradition in China,
which accounts for the fact that Chinese forms of Buddhism (e.g., Ch'an
or Zen Buddhism) show such a heavy dependence on Taoist concepts.
|
|
Structuralism
Levi-Strauss
|
Phenomena can be understood
through the underlying structures and systems of social organisation.
|
|
Scepticism
Xeno,
Pyrrho
|
Sure knowledge may be sought
but not found: our senses are unreliable.
he word skepticism comes from the
Greek word for "looking", and describes the kind of thinker who takes a
wait-and-see attitude regarding just about everything. Skeptics are suspicious
of any claims to knowledge, often to the extreme of total unbelief so
that skepticism can become, in practice, a kind of subjectivism or even
solipsism. Nietzsche and Hume are the two of the major skeptics in philosophy,
but there really is a whole tradition of skepticism stretching from ancient
Greece to the present. Skepticism is not necessarily a bad thing, of course,
and when people talk about a "healthy dose of skepticism" they are referring
to an attitude of questioning and thinking and of not taking conventional
wisdom on faith.
|
|
Perspectivism
Nietzsche,
Quine
|
The external world is to be
interpreted through different alternative systems of concepts and beliefs:
non is more valid than another.
|
|
Naturalism
Strato,
Moore
|
What is studied is all there
is, there is no need for explanation going beyond or outside the universe.
Naturalism usually refers to an
ethical view which holds that at least some human values (though not necessarily
all) are determined by the nature of the human organism and by our situation
on earth values like food, water, shelter, safety, psychological closeness,
actualization of human talent and potential, the attainment of knowledge,
and so on. By way of illustration, existentialism could be considered a
humanistic form of individualism, but it differs from many other forms
of humanism in denying ethical naturalism. In metaphysics, the word naturalism
refers most often to the idea that nature operates according to natural
laws, without spiritual intervention (opposed to theism and spiritualism,
but compatible with deism).
|
|
Nativism
Chomsky
|
The capacity to perceive time
and space is inborn.
|
|
Sensationalism
Ernst
Mach
|
Sensations are the ultimate and
real components of the world: anything can be known through sensory experience
and analysis.
Sensationalism is a radical form
of representationalism which posits that all knowledge is constructed from
or consists in pure sensations (such as blotches of color, pure tones,
etc.). Some adherents go further and claim that we don't have any direct
knowledge of reality, only of sensations. The popular meaning is obviously
non-philosophical and quite unrelated.
|